Thursday, February 14, 2013

Stella Ruvalcaba on Phillip Lopate's "Portrait of My Body"


Reading Phillip Lopates “Portrait of My Body” made me realize how at times we become too harsh with ourselves in terms of appearance. Lopates begins his interpretation of his body and begins with his posture, which I thought was very odd. I had to reread the line various times, “I am a man who tilts,” it’s simplicity caught my attention immediately. He’s very critical of himself almost over analytical. But I respect his honesty and the fact that he decided to share so much about himself. I feel that in order to begin writing about our own sensitive information or quirk we must be willing to reach out to an audience with our imperfections and create a connection. This piece made me realize that in order to be a writer we must be dedicated to art and expose ourselves, imperfections, desires and oddities. You’re no longer writing for yourself create a web of connections with others.
             I didn’t expect the piece to swerve into a more personal direction but I did expect a twist of some sort. I just didn’t think it would involve his penis. I didn’t know 2 pee holes were even possible. I also appreciate writers that set themselves apart by creating unique pieces, like Lopate with “Portrait of My Body”. I had never read a piece that involved an issue so personal and sensitive as the one mentioned in Lopate’s. I appreciate the fact that he’s so honest with the reader, picking out physical aspects of himself that make him uncomfortable. For example, when he mentions his sister telling him he’s gotten “flabby”. Talk about brutally honest. This even made me feel uncomfortable.
            Just as he writes of his imperfections, Lopate also mentions his appreciation for exquisite backs and other characteristics of himself. He compares this with his own back affected by his time spent writing. I noticed there’s an implication that he’s going through a mid-life crisis. He doesn’t feel his age but younger. His mind not catching up with his body. At the same time he seems to describe it, comparing himself then and now. But ends with a final note on his appreciation for his fingers and noting a peculiarity with his right middle finger, broken after a ball game. Throughout the piece he’s sarcastic and too critical of himself and ending with this made me realize the piece has a tone of admiration and underlying pride for himself as a writer.  
            So far, and including this piece, creative non-fiction has showed me that it’s ever expanding in topics and peculiarity. Coming from a poetry concentration, non-fiction has helped me use more description that poetry seems to condense or omit. It’s refreshing to read a detailed piece that guides the reader through peculiarities that makes us all feel unique in a positive way, not shameful or alone. After reading Lopate’s piece I’m realizing there’s no limit to what you can write about. Whatever it is, can be expressed truthfully as “Portrait of My Body” has.

7 comments:

  1. This piece matches up a lot with Lucy Greely's "Mirrorings," and I'd be interested to see the connections and contrasts between the two pieces. I like that you identify "shame" as a primary component of Lopate's subject matter, and how overcoming this shame, in a sense, is a kind of acceptance that transcends personal imperfections. Or perhaps these imperfections simply ARE (rather than "should be") and so, by revealing these to the reader, he also instructs the reader to do the same?

    I'm also interested in this mention you have of making the reader feel "uncomfortable." When do we cross the line into too uncomfortable? Is there a line? And what value is there in making the reader feel uncomfortable within a piece? Really intriguing themes/issues you're dealing with here, Stella.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Between this piece and "Mirrorings" I would have to say that I enjoyed "Mirrorings" much more. For some reason I had a hard time connecting with Lopate's essay. I think a big part of this for me is that he goes into a lot of detail (like Chelsey said below)that I felt was just too much and made it really difficult to finish the piece. I also felt like the piece was more descriptions and less internal thoughts and coming to an understanding about his body. He does connect his body with memories and instances in his life, but I would have really liked to see more of this. "Mirrorings" had more of this internal struggle related to the body which I liked. I was also able to get a sense of how her opinion of her self changed over time and how she grew as a person instead of simply learning more and more details about the author's body.

      Delete
  2. The issue of self-image is a one that may be more important than ever nowadays, especially with the sexualized and polarized world we live in. Do you think this piece contributes to the idea that we over-sexualized our appearances, or that we spend too much effort worrying about them? I know I for one looked a little harder at myself in the mirror than usual after reading this.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Though I appreciate Lopate's writing as good writing, honest and descriptive, I did not especially care for this essay. The extent he goes to describe the details of his body seemed unnecessary and did not make me want to know more about who he is. It might have been more interesting if he has paralleled the physical aspects of his body with a reflection of his internal characteristics/ personality, and they way they could match up or not match up.

      In terms of crossing the line and feeling "uncomfortable", I think there is a line, but that this piece does not cross it. I cannot picture a child reading a piece such as this, and he approaches each part of his body with honest attention to detail, not in any vulgar way.

      Delete
  3. While reading this essay, I did not seem to find it uncomfortable at any point in time, like some may have. I found the author’s reflection to be the most important and best part of the piece, not entirely focusing on the details he gave about his body exactly. This was an interesting piece that really tapped into how one sees themself, and how things have changed, and can still change.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I also really liked this essay, and like you, I mostly appreciated the fact that he was so open and honest. I personally think that that's the best quality a writer can have; by trusting the reader enough (even though they are complete strangers) in to a very personal world of thoughts and noted imperfections. I liked this piece so much, that I used it as the basis for one of my own writing assignments in my journal. I think what I liked most about this piece, other than the honesty from the writer, is the subject matter. It's so relatable because everyone is critical about some part of their body, and although that something is different to everyone, the act of criticizing your own defects is not something you share with just anyone, which goes back to my appreciation for his total trust in the reader.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great, your articles are really very informative and easy to understand. Thanks for this special article. The e visa Turkey is a permit to visit Turkey without any hurdle. you can fully enjoy Turkey . Turkey is a famous destination for tourism .


    ReplyDelete